
PeopleImages // Shutterstock
If you lease a space, you’ve got fewer home-maintenance things to worry about than homeowners do. But renters and their personal property can be just as vulnerable to theft, damage and visitor injury. That’s why it’s smart to purchase renters insurance.
The problem is, these days renters insurance premiums are on the rise. TheZebra explores the reasons why, areas where renters insurance is the least affordable, additional coverage to consider and helpful strategies to keep those premiums affordable.
Why Renters Insurance Costs Are Rising
The average cost of renters insurance nationally is around $171 annually, based on the latest data from the Insurance Information Institute. While that’s a slight increase from the previous year, renters insurance rates have actually come down 9% since 2013.
According to Gitnux, the average monthly premium is $15, with Mississippi being the state with the highest average renters insurance rates at approximately $252 per year.
A 2024 report by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia found that more rental insurance policyholders (by 23.5 percentage points) experienced year-over-year premium increases than those who reported premium decreases.
Among the culprits? Inflation, increased crime rates, higher coverage limits and severe weather claims (more on this next). Consider that the average property damage loss per renters insurance claim is estimated at $10,000. Lightning and fire claims are the most costly associated loss, averaging more than $11,000 per claim, while theft comprises almost 1 in 5 renters insurance claims, per Gitnux.
“Higher local crime rates, liability claims and medical expenses all contribute to higher rates, as does inflation and personal property values. The cost of household goods, ranging from electronics to furniture, has increased — leading insurers to adjust the contents coverage and raise overall premiums,” says Maya-Rae Woods, an account manager with All Solutions Insurance Agency LLC.
Dennis Shirshikov, a professor of finance and economics at City University of New York/Queens College, also points to higher construction labor costs, steeper replacement material prices, increases in theft claims in dense urban areas and elevated liability payouts.
“Insurers have also adjusted premiums to reflect reinsurance costs that climbed during recent years of heightened catastrophic events, and this cost is passed through to policyholders,” he adds.
Truth is, renters insurance prices are going up for many of the same reasons why everything else in the economy feels more expensive, according to Beth Sw